The Discoveroids then proceed to weave their own dogma canada
Misinformation about Information
canada goose coats on sale You know about the Discovery Institute claim that the universe is comprised of some kind of supernatural pixie dust they call about which canada goose outlet ontario we wrote Phlogiston, Vitalism, and canada goose uk Information. canada goose coats on sale
canada goose uk black friday Despite the intentional similarity in terminology, the magical phenomenon the Discoveroids call information has nothing to do with information theory, which Wikipedia says canada goose outlet toronto location is to have been founded in 1948 by Claude Shannon. No one can detect Discoveroid information with the instruments of science, yet they claim they can somehow sense its presence by using William Dembski’s Design Inference, commonly called his Design Filter. We wrote about it canada goose uk store here: The Discoveroids and Their Magic Filter. canada goose uk black friday
canada goose clearance As the canada goose outlet authentic Discoveroid dogma has evolved, it appears that the principal function of their intelligent designer blessed be he! is to make things complicated. To do canada goose outlet store calgary that he adds the mystical ingredient of information. They say it’s not matter, not energy, not anything you know. It’s information! And it’s a big deal. It permeates canada goose outlet england the entire universe. It’s in your DNA. And only the Discoveroids can detect its canada goose outlet uk fake presence. canada goose clearance
canada goose black friday sale But they just received or misappropriated a canada goose outlet ottawa big canada goose coats uk gift, thanks to some unfortunate language in a paper published in PLOS Biology, a peer reviewd journal. The article is canada goose outlet online reviews sensibly titled: An Estimate of the Total DNA in canada goose victoria parka outlet the Biosphere. You can read it online without a subscription. The abstract says: canada goose black friday sale
cheap Canada Goose Modern whole organism genome analysis, in combination with biomass estimates, allows us to estimate a lower bound on the total information content in the biosphere: 5.3 1031 (3.6 1031) megabases (Mb) of DNA. Given conservative estimates regarding DNA transcription rates, this information content suggests biosphere processing speeds exceeding yottaNOPS values (1024 Nucleotide Operations Per Second). Although prokaryotes evolved at least 3 billion years before plants and animals, we find that the information content of prokaryotes is similar to plants and animals canada goose outlet uk at the present day. This information based approach offers a new way to quantify anthropogenic and natural processes in the biosphere and its canada goose outlet factory information diversity over time. cheap Canada Goose
canada goose Note that they refer to and natural processes. That seems to refer to both man caused and naturally occurring complexity. We get back to that in a moment. canada goose
buy canada goose jacket The Discoveroids have seized upon the paper use of the word to claim that it about their designer magic pixie canada goose outlet toronto dust. This new article appears at their creationist blog, without a byline: Earth Biosphere Is canada goose outlet buffalo Awash in Information. Here are some excerpts, with bold font added by us: buy canada goose jacket
Canada Goose Online Visualize an exoplanet far away: dynamic, comfortable, yet lifeless. It has water, canada goose outlet locations in toronto plate tectonics, volcanoes, an atmosphere and all the ingredients for life but no life. What would be the primary factor distinguishing it from Earth? A new paper in PLOS Biology suggests that its chief www.ecanadagoose.co.uk drawback, all things being equal, would be a lack of complex specified information. Canada Goose Online
Canada Goose sale BWAHAHAHAHAHA! No, the paper doesn anything about what canada goose vest outlet the Discoveroids call specified complexity. Wikipedia says: Canada Goose sale
cheap canada goose uk Specified complexity is what Dembski terms an filter which can recognize design by detecting specified information (CSI). cheap canada goose uk
uk canada goose outlet Let’s canada goose outlet 80 off read on canada goose outlet new york in the Discoveroid blog canada goose outlet jackets post: uk canada goose outlet
buy canada goose jacket cheap As a side note, they never explain their odd distinction between and (are humans not natural?). Their last sentence just canada goose stockists uk says, approach may canada goose jacket outlet uk help us understand the changing complexity of the biosphere over time and to predict in new ways, both anthropogenic and natural, canada goose outlet us future changes in the biosphere. Apparently even typical astrobiologists have an intuitive sense of human exceptionalism. The Discoveroids then proceed to weave their own dogma canada goose outlet price into the published paper statements, but their efforts are so contrived and tortured that we going to skip most of it. Here another excerpt: buy canada goose jacket cheap
Canada Goose Parka The rest of the paper discusses how the researchers arrived at their numbers and how the values might canada goose outlet store near me have varied over time. (They estimated that the information content in prokaryotes, the simplest organisms, is similar to that of higher organisms within two orders of magnitude, which they found surprising.) They also include caveats about assumptions and uncertainties in their measurements and offer canada goose outlet store uk suggestions for answering future questions. The whole paper is very interesting. Canada Goose Parka
It particularly interesting because the paper canada goose outlet washington dc is talking about something real and identifiable. It says: calculating the total amount of DNA, we are assuming that every base pair is a unique piece of information. That totally unlike the Discoveroids pixie dust information which they never even attempted to quantify, or meaningfully define. They continue:
canadian goose jacket But the damage is done. Even if canada goose outlet in usa their estimates need to be canada goose outlet belgium revised by a terabase or two some day, they have made it clear that our biosphere is awash in information. canadian goose jacket
Canada Goose online BWAHAHAHAHAHA! Yes, the biosphere is in information (DNA base pairs) but that not the Discoveroids magical version of information. Here’s one final excerpt: Canada Goose online
uk canada goose Though clearly evolutionists, they have presented a significant challenge to scientific materialism to account for all this processing power. Simultaneously, they demonstrate the fruitfulness of an information based approach to the investigation of life. uk canada goose
canada goose uk outlet So there you are. A published paper that merely estimates the amount of information contained in the world DNA has been transformed by the Discoveroids into confirmation of their own kind of magic information, which is created only by their supernatural designer. In canada goose outlet london the future, they canada goose outlet mall probably include the PLOS Biology paper in their listing of peer reviewed papers that support their of intelligent design. The Sensuous Curmudgeon. canada goose uk outlet
Canada Goose Outlet By this definition of canada goose clothing uk a bacteria splitting in two creates many canada goose outlet boston megabytes of I have said before, the overwhelming majority of information in the universe is created by natural processes. When crestionists/ID proponents say no natural process can create information, they are either lying or pulling bait and switch. Canada Goose Outlet
canada goose store Since almost all information is created canada goose outlet in canada by natural processes, when we find information in biology, we should assume a priori that biology was created by natural canada goose outlet black friday processes, unless and until extraordinary canada goose outlet in uk evidence proves otherwise. canada goose store
Canada Goose Jackets After reading the PLOS article, I think it is interesting that the Discoveroids don comment on the fact that, although the biosphere is in information prokaryotes, and among eukaryotes, plants, contain several orders of magnitude more than animals (and I estimate the total animal amount is several orders of magnitude more than the amount for humans). So once again, it clear that if the Discoveroids favorite sky fairy (blessed be his/her/its name) scattered all that information about, he/she/it put much more effort into information for things that are not what the Discoveroids think is his/her/its favorite organism! Canada Goose Jackets
canada goose factory sale Let us assume that there canada goose parka uk is a well defined quantity that the ID people have identified. canada goose factory sale
canada goose clearance sale Why should we think that there is conservation of that quantity? canada goose clearance sale
Canada Goose Coats On Sale The ID people accept that the canada goose outlet 2015 quantity can spontaneously decrease. Canada Goose Coats On Sale
canada goose coats Is there a way of testing that it cannot spontaneously increase? canada goose coats
canada goose uk shop Actually, the ID people have pointed out that a human agency can cause an increase. Can we think of canada goose outlet florida any other conserved quantity for canada goose shop uk which human agency is exempt canada goose uk shop.